Walk-In vs Cabinet Pantries

Walk-In vs Cabinet Pantries: Space Planning Considerations for Residential Kitchens

It seems straightforward in principle, until you look at the floor plan.

You have either a dedicated room (walk-in) with potential storage along multiple walls, or a pantry cabinet next to your cooking space with vertical storage. Both options allow ample food storage, but differ significantly in the space required to achieve it.

Many considerations go into deciding which option is preferable, including available space, quantity of goods to be stored, frequency of access, etc. This should be established before specifying any cabinetry details.

What You’ll Learn

  • A Walk-In Pantry Requires Additional Footprint
  • A Cabinet Pantry Maximizes Available Wall Space
  • Quantity & Frequency of Goods Stored
  • Accessibility & Obstruction
  • Cost Implications
  • Conclusions – determining your preferred option

A Walk-In Pantry Requires Additional Footprint

As implied by the name, you are afforded a whole room to store your goods in a walk-in pantry, with the ability to utilize all or most of the surrounding walls for shelves.

However, this is not the only space consumed by a walk-in pantry.

You will also require space to access the pantry and manoeuvre within it to retrieve and deposit your goods. Depending on the amount of shelving, the room may seem more constricted once it is fitted.

You should account for shelving depth and residual free-standing space within the room to compare available storage capacity. Confirm the location of the pantry door(s) and ensure it does not impede the kitchen circulation or access to any appliances (e.g. fridge/freezer).

Consider also the proximity of the pantry to your cooking area. Further afield may allow more space within the room, but you’ll be travelling further to/from your food when cooking. Conversely, a less spacious pantry closer to the cooktop may prove more convenient.

Where possible, convert an existing closet, alcove or adjoining room into a walk-in pantry, provided this doesn’t reduce essential kitchen working space or circulation.

Alternatively, if you wish to include appliances within your pantry, additional provisions will need to be made to allow for these e.g. counter benching to suit the appliance footprint(s), power and possibly exhaust/ventilation. The NKBA 2027 Kitchen Trends Report indicates that surveyed industry professionals expect pantries to serve more functions beyond food storage. As such, allow sufficient space to comfortably accommodate your desired functionality.

A Cabinet Pantry Maximises Available Wall Space

No additional room space is needed for a cabinet pantry, only space within the kitchen and/or external wall space, typically incorporating tall doors/shelving/drawers/pull-outs to maximise vertical capacity. You will still need clear floor space in front to open the doors or pull-outs and retrieve items.

This can be beneficial if a walk-in pantry would unduly encroach on your working kitchen space. Custom Pantry Cabinets can be configured to suit with various combinations of shelves and drawer/pull-out arrangements.

According to the 2026 U.S. Houzz Kitchen Trends Study, 47% of surveyed U.S. homeowners with recent or planned kitchen renovations selected pantry cabinets as a built-in feature.

Maximise the vertical dimension of your pantry cabinet with appropriately placed shelves and pull-out arrangements – e.g. commonly accessed food mid-height, bulkier items on lower levels, and lighter infrequently-used items higher up. Beware of deeper shelving hiding items towards the rear – consider drawers/pull-outs here if accessibility to these areas is important.

Note that pull-outs will require additional clearance to project from the cabinet. Ensure sufficient space to open the drawer/pull-out in full, avoiding conflicts with other features/fixtures (e.g. benchtop island, appliances) and allowing adequate clearance to walk past. You don’t want to introduce a pinch point or otherwise impede circulation within your kitchen!

For tall pantry cabinets abutting a benchtop/island, check clearance once doors are open to the maximum extent and consider the effect of two narrower paired cabinet doors, which can reduce how far each leaf swings into the aisle depending on the hinge arrangement. Alternatively, exposed shelving allows greater visibility but leaves your food exposed.

Quantity & Frequency of Goods Stored

Obviously, more shelf space = more storage, but this isn’t necessarily the end of the story.

Consider your requirements in terms of the type of goods you purchase/store (in volume) and how frequently you’ll need to access them. If you purchase large quantities of food and/or other household goods infrequently (e.g., a monthly shop), a walk-in pantry is likely to suit, with generous storage space (and possibly floor access for large/bulky items). On the other hand, if you purchase smaller quantities more frequently and need to access these items regularly, then a pantry cabinet in close proximity to your primary benchtop may be more beneficial.

List your desired storage requirements in broad categories, such as:

  • Commonly accessed food (e.g. daily breakfast, beverages, baking essentials, pantry staples)
  • Larger/bulkier goods (e.g. cartons of juice, larger bottles/jugs, backup staples)
  • Appliances/equipment (e.g. appliances, baking trays/platters)
  • Other infrequently accessed items

Assess the approximate dimensions of your key items to confirm suitability for the pantry configuration you choose (e.g. will your stand mixer fit?). Variable shelf heights can also provide flexibility to adapt as necessary.

Regardless of storage format, your pantry will need to be maintained and kept free from contaminants/pests, etc.

Accessibility & Obstruction

Consider the traffic flow through your kitchen and identify where obstructions may be caused by opening the pantry door(s) or accessing your pantry.

Position the walk-in door/pantry cabinet door(s) so as to minimize conflicts with key traffic flows and appliance operation. It’s helpful to map out your typical movements through the kitchen (e.g. fridge -> sink -> benchtop -> oven/cooktop etc.) and overlay this with pantry usage/access.

Walk through some typical kitchen tasks (loading/unloading groceries, cooking, cleaning, etc.) to understand the flow and interactions with the pantry, who will be standing where and which doors will be open?

Similarly, consider the ease of accessing items stored in the pantry – you’ll want easy access to your everyday items and ideally won’t want to be lifting heavier items above head height. Pull-out shelves can aid access to the deeper levels of pantry cabinets; a walk-in will generally allow better visual overview of shelving.

Ensure adequate pantry lighting (internal to tall cupboards or for a walk-in) and plan for any power points or appliance requirements.

Cost Implications

A walk-in pantry may not always equate to a higher cost. If you have an existing space that can be utilized as a walk-in, it may only require internal fittings (shelving, lighting, power, etc.), whereas a cabinet pantry may incur more cost in carpentry/cabinetry and fixtures. However, if a new walk-in room needs to be created, this can be more costly in terms of masonry/renovation works and associated finishing (flooring, paint, lighting, power, etc.).

Likewise, a cabinet pantry may avoid additional room renovations but cost more in cabinetry and associated fixtures (doors/handles, finishes, lighting, power points, appliances, etc.).

Ensure you compare quotes on like-for-like terms and request an allowance/scope of works covering the full installation (not only cabinetry/shelving). Determine what storage capacity/functionality you can achieve with your allocated budget.

Conclusions – determining your preferred option

In summary, a walk-in pantry is well-suited to homes with sufficient available floor space in close proximity to the kitchen, requiring ample storage space and/or provision for appliances. It can also be conveniently located in an existing built-in/room to avoid sacrificing kitchen working space.

A cabinet pantry is advantageous where floor space is at a premium and/or you want ready access to your food and supplies near your primary cooking/benchtop area (e.g. during a kitchen renovation that is not reconfiguring the kitchen layout). A well-designed arrangement of shelving, drawers and pull-outs can maximize the space available to you.

You may even consider a combination of a cabinet pantry and a supplementary walk-in room/storage area for less frequently accessed or larger items, to reduce congestion in each respective space.

Take the time to mark up and test your proposed pantry space, checking clearance to other fixtures/features and confirming easy access to your key items.

Ultimately, you’re looking for a solution that complements your kitchen, enabling you to cook efficiently without your pantry getting in the way.

Scroll to Top